12
Mar
2020

Graduate school versus industry R&D

March 12th, 2020 in Learning

Graduate school analytical chemist Private industry analytical chemist
Main goal: produce a dissertation and defend it in front of experts Main goal: generate business through analytical services
The novelty of the idea sells The utility of the idea sells
Go deeper into the problem to solve it as thoroughly as possible to demonstrate understanding Go deep enough into the problem to solve it adequately and quickly to demonstrate reliable results
Control the system enough to see the trend and report

Control the system thoroughly so as to have data others can rely on at any point in time, even in a court of law

Purchase something for $50 and wait 1 month

Purchase the same product for $200 to get it the next day

YOU SPENT TOO MUCH MONEY!

WHY DIDN'T YOU BUY 3 OF THEM?!

It looks like the analyte is there! It's not there.
The analyte is there! The analyte is below detection limit, so it's not there
The analyte is not there! The analyte is there and you're not seeing it because your instruments are 20 years old and your lab is not standardized
This won't work: There's carryover! There is carryover at 1% MDL. Still works!
What's a MDL? Check the SOP.
What's a SOP? One sec, I need to load samples.
Can I have some samples? No but you can help me load these ones.
I'm going to go read research articles I'm going to go skim research articles for numbers on detection limits and run conditions for a new method
I amassed a well-curated library of journal articles I used some journal articles for that SOP
THAT IDEA WILL NOT WORK BECAUSE A, B, C... Let's just run the test and see.
Don't necessarily do everything the PI says Do what the boss says, even if it's wrong
No time do develop a method that I know works consistently No time to play with methods that don't work consistently
Research then possibly development Development then possibly research
Does it work at all? Does it work consistently?
Talk to your PI once a week Talk to your PM multiple times a day
Stick to your year(s)-long project Get ready to change your year-long project this Monday
No one around you knows what they're doing (i.e. they're learning) Everyone around you knows what they're doing (and they're learning)
Don't touch my fumehood! Any of your workers could be touching your fumehood.
YOU DID WHAT?! WRITE DOWN WHAT YOU DID!
DAMN, I FORGOT TO PREP THE STANDARD! Here's your standard.☺
PhD doesn't guarantee you a job Industry needs more PhDs!
I am never doing grad school again Should I go to graduate school?